Pin it
I simply had to share my favorite potato recipe with you! These Crispy Potato Stacks with Garlic Herb Butter have become legendary at my family gatherings. Every time I make them, they disappear within minutes - my sister-in-law actually hovers near the oven waiting for the next batch! The edges get perfectly crispy and ruffled while the centers stay creamy and tender. I've learned to make a double batch because they're always the first dish to vanish from the table.
What Makes These So Incredible
After years of potato experimentation, I've found these stacks to be simply magical. The contrast between those crispy, golden edges and the buttery-soft centers creates the perfect bite. That garlic herb butter seeps down between every layer, infusing the potatoes with amazing flavor. They're elegant enough for holiday dinners but easy enough for Sunday supper!
Pin it
Let's Talk Ingredients
- The Perfect Potatoes: I prefer Yukon Golds for their buttery flavor, but Russets work beautifully too. Just make sure they're fresh and firm.
- That Magic Butter Mixture: Fresh herbs make all the difference here! I grow thyme and rosemary in my kitchen window just for recipes like this.
- The Finishing Touch: A sprinkle of flaky sea salt at the end makes these absolutely irresistible.
Let's Make Some Magic
- Prep Those Potatoes
- This is where your mandolin becomes your best friend. I aim for slices so thin you can almost see through them - they'll crisp up beautifully this way.
- The Butter Bath
- Warm melted butter mixed with fresh herbs creates the most amazing aroma in your kitchen. Make sure every slice gets coated!
- Stack With Care
- Take your time layering in the muffin tin. I like to fan them slightly, like a deck of cards, for extra crispy edges.
- The Bake
- Keep an eye on them - when the edges start curling up and turning golden, you're getting close to perfection.
- The Grand Finale
- That final sprinkle of flaky salt is non-negotiable - it makes all the flavors pop!
My Top Tips for Success
- Mandolin Safety First: Please use the guard! I learned this lesson the hard way - a cut finger isn't worth the time saved.
- Get Them Snug: Really press those layers together in the muffin tin. They'll hold their shape better when serving.
- Watch That Broiler: If you're going for extra crispiness, don't walk away! They can go from golden to burnt in seconds.
Plan Ahead Like a Pro
- Make It Easy: I often prep these early in the day when I'm less rushed, then finish them just before dinner.
- Smart Storage: If you're prepping ahead, keep those sliced potatoes in cold water to prevent browning. Just dry them really well before adding the butter!
Pin it
Essential Equipment
- That Trusty Mandolin: It's worth the investment just for this recipe. Mine has paid for itself in time saved!
- Muffin Tin Magic: A standard muffin tin works perfectly. I actually bought an extra one just for these potatoes.
- Sharp Knife Option: If you're skilled with a knife, you can absolutely slice by hand. Just aim for consistent thickness.
Perfect Pairings
These stacks steal the show at any meal! They're amazing alongside a holiday roast, but we love them just as much with a simple grilled chicken. I've even served them at brunch - they pair beautifully with eggs and bacon.
Keeping and Reheating
- Quick Storage: On the rare occasion we have leftovers, they'll keep for a few days in the fridge.
- Crispy Comeback: A quick trip in a hot oven brings back that wonderful crispy texture - no microwaving, please!
Why Everyone Loves These
It's the combination of textures that makes these irresistible! The crispy edges remind me of potato chips, while the centers stay creamy like perfectly roasted potatoes. Plus, they look so impressive on the plate - everyone thinks you spent hours making them!
Pin it
Change It Up
While the classic herb blend is incredible, don't be afraid to experiment! In fall, I love using sage and thyme. Spring calls for fresh dill and chives. Each variation brings something special to the table.
The Cheese Option
Want to take these over the top? Try adding some freshly grated Parmesan between the layers. It creates these amazing crispy cheese bits on the edges that are absolutely divine! Gruyère works beautifully too.
Presentation Pro Tips
These little stacks are naturally beautiful, but I love making them extra special for guests. A few fresh herb sprigs scattered around the serving plate, maybe some edible flowers for special occasions. They look like they came from a fancy restaurant!
Party Perfect
These have become my go-to for entertaining because they're such crowd pleasers. You can prep them ahead, they look stunning, and everyone loves them. Plus, they hold their heat well, so they're perfect for buffet-style serving.
Pin it
Kids Love Them Too
For the little ones, I keep it simple - just butter and a touch of garlic powder. My nieces call them 'potato towers' and love how they can pull apart the layers. It's a fun way to get kids excited about eating their vegetables!
Pure Comfort Food
There's something so satisfying about these potato stacks. Maybe it's the way they combine the best parts of every potato dish - the crispiness of chips, the creaminess of mashed potatoes, and the herb-infused flavor of roasted potatoes. Whatever it is, they never fail to make people happy!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make these ahead of time?
- Yes, either prepare fully and reheat, or slice and coat potatoes with herb butter ahead. The butter helps prevent browning when prepped in advance.
- → How thin should I slice the potatoes?
- Slice potatoes about 1/16 inch thick, preferably using a mandolin for even slices. Even thickness ensures proper cooking.
- → Why use a muffin tin?
- The muffin tin helps shape the stacks and ensures even cooking, creating perfectly portioned servings with crispy edges.
- → How do I know when they're done?
- Test with a wooden skewer - it should easily slide through. They should be tender inside with golden brown, crispy edges.
- → Can I use different herbs?
- While thyme and parsley work beautifully, you can experiment with other fresh herbs like rosemary or sage.