Mexican Chocolate Chile Pie

This Mexican chocolate pie brings together the unexpected magic of sweet, salty, and spicy. Rich cocoa and dark chocolate swirl with a gentle heat from ground chili, all layered in a crunchy cookie crust. The result is a dessert that is equal parts comfort and adventure, perfect when you want something a little daring for your next gathering.

I first made this for a Dia de los Muertos potluck I was nervous it would be too spicy but everyone asked for seconds and could not stop talking about the creamy filling and kick of chili.

Ingredients

• Dry cookies: Choose a sturdy not-too-sweet cookie like digestive or Maria For the crust to hold up well look for fresh ones and avoid overly sweet options
• Butter: Good quality adds richness to the base Unsalted works best so you control the salt
• Sugar: Sweetens both crust and filling Use fine granulated for easy dissolving
• Ground cinnamon: Adds depth and a warm undertone Pick a fresh jar for the best flavor
• Egg white: Helps bind the crust together ensuring a solid shell
• Salt: A pinch lifts all the flavors and balances sweetness Use pure sea salt if possible
• Cornstarch: Thickens the filling to just the right cling Make sure it is lump free
• Cocoa powder: Brings real chocolate flavor Dutch process is ideal but natural works if that is what you have
• Instant coffee: Deepens the chocolate flavor with a subtle boost Choose a smooth mild variety
• Ground chili: Gives gentle heat and that authentic Mexican flair Go for ancho chili if you want mild and smoky
• Eggs and egg yolks: Combine for a lush and smooth custard use fresh eggs for best results
• Full fat milk: Adds creaminess and richness Choose whole milk
• Dark chocolate: The soul of the dessert Use chocolate with at least 60 percent cacao for deep flavor Chop just before using for freshness

Step-by-Step Instructions

Make the cookie crust:

Crush cookies using a food processor blender or rolling pin You want fine crumbs for a sturdy crust Save a spoonful for garnish later Melt butter gently and let it cool for a few minutes to avoid scrambling the egg white later

Mix and press:

In a bowl stir together cookie crumbs melted butter egg white cinnamon and a pinch of salt Mix well until all the crumbs are moist and the mixture holds together when pressed Transfer to a greased springform Press firmly and evenly across the bottom and slightly up the sides for a neat edge

Bake the crust:

Place the springform in a preheated oven at 190 degrees Celsius or 375 degrees Fahrenheit Bake for about ten minutes Watch for a golden brown hue which signals the crust is toasted and set Let it cool completely for the best texture

Prepare the chocolate filling base:

In a mixer bowl stir together sugar salt cornstarch cocoa powder instant coffee chili and egg yolks Add eggs one by one beat until fully incorporated and you have a smooth thick mixture

Heat milk and melt chocolate:

Warm the milk in a medium sized pan over gentle heat Once steaming but not boiling add chopped dark chocolate Stir until melted and smooth

Temper the egg mixture:

With the mixer running slowly pour in the hot milk and chocolate blend This helps avoid scrambling the eggs Keep whisking to make a glossy batter

Cook the custard:

Return the mixture to the pan and place over low heat Stir constantly with a whisk or spatula until it thickens about five minutes Pay close attention so it does not stick or form lumps

Cool and fill the crust:

Set the pan with thickened custard mixture into a larger bowl of cold water Stir occasionally over ten minutes to prevent a skin from forming or lumps from developing

Assemble and chill:

When the custard has cooled a bit pour it into the cooled pie crust Smooth the top cover tightly with cling film pressing the wrap directly onto the surface Chill in the refrigerator for at least three hours so it sets fully

Garnish and serve:

Remove pie from fridge Garnish with reserved cookie crumbs for a little crunch Slice and enjoy cold for best texture

Pin it

I love using a big bar of Mexican chocolate for this pie The added cinnamon and hint of spice in the chocolate take everything up a notch and remind me of the family bakery trips in Oaxaca My kids always sneak the cookie crumbs before I can garnish the pie so I now hide a little extra for topping

Storage Tips

Keep your Mexican chocolate pie in the fridge tightly wrapped This pie holds its texture and flavor for three to four days A cold setting is crucial for the custard to stay creamy and not get watery I do not recommend freezing since the texture can turn grainy once thawed

Ingredient Substitutions

For the cookies graham crackers or plain chocolate biscuits work just as well If you do not want any heat swap out the chili for a touch more cinnamon For a dairy free version use plant based butter and unsweetened almond or oat milk The pie will still be rich though the flavor will shift slightly

Serving Suggestions

Slice the pie and serve with a dollop of softly whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream For real celebration dust with a little extra cinnamon or a drizzle of warm chocolate sauce Some fresh raspberries or orange zest on the side are stunning too

Pin it

Cultural Context

Chocolate in Mexico dates back to the Aztec empire where it was treasured as a drink and food of the gods Adding chili and cinnamon is a classic pairing that showcases both tradition and bold flavor layers This pie is a contemporary take that pays homage to that legacy while making it easy for a home cook to enjoy anytime

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What makes this chocolate pie uniquely Mexican?

The inclusion of rich dark chocolate, ground chilli, cinnamon, and a hint of coffee creates a complex balance of flavors associated with Mexican desserts.

→ How spicy is the filling?

The level of spiciness is subtle; the chilli enhances the chocolate's depth but doesn’t overwhelm. Start with less if you prefer mild heat.

→ Can I use other types of cookies for the crust?

Yes, digestive biscuits, graham crackers, or similar dry cookies work well. Adjust added sugar depending on sweetness.

→ How long does the pie need to set?

It's best chilled for at least 3 hours to allow the filling to firm up. Overnight chilling enhances texture and flavor.

→ What garnishes complement this dessert?

Sprinkle extra cookie crumbs, a dusting of cocoa, or add whipped cream for a rich finishing touch.

→ Is it possible to make this dessert ahead?

Absolutely. Prepare and chill the pie a day in advance for seamless serving and best flavor development.